Is Simply Business or buying direct from Hiscox cheaper for a new LLC?

CoverBench is reader-supported. When you get a quote or buy a policy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our rankings or recommendations.

You just formed an LLC. The bank wants proof of insurance, a client contract has a "must carry general liability" clause, or a landlord needs a certificate before you sign a lease — and now you're staring at two very different ways to get covered: buy direct from a single insurer like Hiscox, or shop a marketplace like Simply Business that quotes several carriers from one form.

The question almost every new owner types into a search bar is the same: is it cheaper to buy insurance direct, or through a marketplace? The honest answer is that "cheaper" isn't really the deciding factor for a brand-new LLC — both routes pull from the same competitive market, and the real fork is speed and simplicity versus carrier choice. Here's where each one wins for a company with zero policies today.

Everything below is research-based, drawn from each provider's published coverage descriptions, online-quoting explainers, and reports from users. We have not purchased a policy or run a live quote, so nothing here is a quote, a rate, or a guarantee of price.

Not insurance advice. CoverBench is an independent comparison resource, not a licensed insurance agent, broker, or advisor. This is general information and may not reflect your situation, your state's requirements, or current rates. Verify coverage, terms, and price directly with the insurer before purchasing.

The short answer for a new LLC

If you already know roughly what you need — say, a single general liability or Business Owner's Policy for a low-risk service or professional business — and you want a certificate of insurance in your inbox fast, buying direct from Hiscox Small Business Insurance is usually the simpler path. You answer one set of questions, you get one policy, you're done.

If you don't know which carrier fits, or your trade is something carriers price very differently (anything with employees, physical risk, or workers' comp needs), running one intake through the Simply Business Marketplace to see several carriers side by side is the smarter first move — it surfaces options you'd otherwise have to hunt for one website at a time.

Featured-partner disclosure. Hiscox and Simply Business are both CoverBench CJ partners (programs pending approval), so we may earn a commission if you get a quote or buy through our links — at no extra cost to you. Commissions never change our rankings. Both links below are where to compare and apply, not live-rate offers; rates and plans change, so always check current terms on the provider's site.

Direct vs marketplace: what actually differs

These two aren't competing products so much as two different buying models, and that's the part new owners miss.

Buying direct (Hiscox) means you deal with one insurer end to end — one quote, one policy, one place to manage renewals and claims. Hiscox is widely described as one of the more online-friendly direct insurers for small and low-risk businesses, with self-serve quoting and monthly payment options that suit a freshly formed LLC watching cash flow. The trade-off: a single insurer's appetite and price won't fit every trade, and you only see one company's number.

Using a marketplace (Simply Business) means one intake returns quotes from several partner carriers. For a new LLC with no insurer relationship yet, that's the fastest way to see a range of prices without filling out five separate forms. The trade-off: a marketplace is a broker layer, so depending on your trade some quotes may need carrier follow-up, and you'll manage the policy through whichever carrier you pick.

A useful way to frame it: direct is one good answer fast; a marketplace is several answers to compare. Neither is inherently cheaper — price comes from the carrier underwriting your specific business, not the storefront you bought through.

Hiscox vs Simply Business for a new LLC: side by side

The table below compares the two on the dimensions that actually matter when you have no coverage yet. Cost figures are illustrative ranges from public small-business averages, not quotes — your real number depends on your industry, revenue, payroll, location, and claims history. Check current terms with each provider.

Check current options: Hiscox Small Business Insurance — Simply Business Marketplace

(Both providers are CJ partners and pending program approval; the links above are where to compare and apply, not live-rate guarantees. Rates and plans change — confirm current terms directly with each provider.)

When buying direct from Hiscox wins

For a new LLC, the direct route tends to win when:

• You're a low-risk or professional business — consultants, designers, IT freelancers, coaches and similar advice-based LLCs are a natural fit for a single insurer. Hiscox is frequently cited in user reports for strong professional-liability (E&O) terms for these trades.
• You need a certificate of insurance today — when a client contract or landlord is the only reason you're buying, one quote-and-bind flow is the shortest path from "no coverage" to "certificate in hand."
• You want one bill and one renewal to manage — a solo or very small LLC often values simplicity over squeezing out the last few dollars.

If that's you, start a quote with Hiscox Small Business Insurance and you'll usually have a clear single number to act on quickly.

When the Simply Business marketplace wins

The marketplace route tends to win when a new LLC has uncertainty one insurer can't fully answer:

• You don't know which carrier fits your trade — riskier or specialized trades (physical work, products, food, vehicles) get priced very differently across carriers, so seeing several quotes protects you from one company's appetite.
• You're hiring, or expect to — once employees enter the picture, workers' comp is usually legally required (confirm your state's rules), and comparing comp carriers in one pass beats chasing them individually.
• You want a real price comparison before committing — for a brand-new LLC with no insurer relationship, a marketplace is the fastest way to learn what "normal" looks like for your business.

If that's you, run one intake through the Simply Business Marketplace and let the comparison surface the options worth a closer look.

Is it actually cheaper one way or the other?

Let's answer it plainly: for most new LLCs there is no reliable, built-in price advantage to either model. Both providers draw from the same competitive market, and your premium is set by the carrier underwriting your business — industry, revenue, payroll, location, claims history — not by whether you arrived through a direct site or a marketplace.

What changes is your odds of finding the cheapest fit. A marketplace raises those odds by showing more carriers in one pass (useful when your trade is priced inconsistently); a direct insurer can match or beat it when your business is a clean fit for that insurer's appetite (common for low-risk professional LLCs). The smartest, genuinely free move is to do both — get a fast direct quote from Hiscox as a baseline, run one Simply Business intake to see the range, then pick the lower number for equivalent coverage.

The bottom line

For a brand-new LLC, the choice isn't really "which is cheaper" — it's "do I want one good answer fast, or several answers to compare?" Know what you need and want a certificate quickly? Buy direct from Hiscox Small Business Insurance. Unsure which carrier fits, or about to hire? Shop the Simply Business Marketplace first. Because comparing is free, getting one quote from each and choosing the lower price for the same coverage almost always leaves a new owner better off. Just check current terms on each site before you buy, since rates and plans change.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to buy small business insurance direct or through a marketplace?

Neither model is reliably cheaper on its own. Both pull from the same competitive carrier market, and your premium is set by the carrier underwriting your specific business — industry, revenue, payroll, location, and claims history. A marketplace raises your odds of finding the lowest number because you see more carriers at once; a direct insurer can match or beat it when your business is a clean fit. The only way to know for sure is to compare equivalent quotes from each. This is general information, not insurance advice.

Do I need business insurance the moment I form an LLC?

Forming an LLC doesn't automatically require insurance, but several real triggers usually do: a client contract demanding proof of general liability, a landlord requiring a certificate before a lease, a lender's condition, or hiring employees (which typically makes workers' comp legally required — confirm your state's rules). Many new owners buy a general liability or Business Owner's Policy first because it's what contracts most often ask for. Confirm your specific requirements with the party requesting coverage and verify current terms with the insurer.

What's the difference between Hiscox and Simply Business?

Hiscox is a single direct insurer — you get one quote and one policy from one company, with a reputation for online-friendly quoting and strong professional-liability terms for low-risk trades. Simply Business is a marketplace — one form returns quotes from several partner carriers, which helps when you want to compare options or shop workers' comp. Direct is one answer fast; a marketplace is several answers to compare.

Can I get a certificate of insurance fast as a new LLC?

Often yes. Direct online insurers like Hiscox are frequently reported by users to let you quote, buy, and download a certificate of insurance quickly online — useful when a contract or landlord is your reason for buying. Through a marketplace, timing depends on which carrier you choose, since some quotes may involve follow-up. Confirm exact timing and document availability with the provider before relying on it.

Should I just get quotes from both Hiscox and Simply Business?

For most new LLCs, yes — and it costs nothing. Getting a fast direct quote from Hiscox gives you a baseline, and running one marketplace intake through Simply Business shows you the range across several carriers. Then you simply pick the lower price for equivalent coverage. Comparing is free and is the only way to actually know which route is cheaper for your specific business. Always check current terms on each provider's site, since rates and plans change.