Simply Business review: is the marketplace worth it for shopping carriers?

CoverBench is reader-supported. When you get a quote or buy a policy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our rankings or recommendations.

If you have searched for small business insurance, you have almost certainly run into Simply Business — in "compare quotes" ads, in best-insurer roundups, and in results for niche trades like cleaners, contractors, or personal trainers. But Simply Business is not actually an insurance company. It is a marketplace, and that distinction changes who it is right for.

This review explains what Simply Business is, how the marketplace model works, where it genuinely helps owners, and where buying direct from a single carrier serves you better. Everything below is research-based, drawn from Simply Business's own published service descriptions, coverage explainers, and reports from users. We have not purchased a policy or run our own quote, and nothing here is a quote or a guarantee of price.

Not insurance advice. CoverBench is an independent comparison resource, not a licensed insurance agent, broker, or advisor. This is general information and may not reflect your situation, your state's requirements, or current rates. Verify coverage, terms, and price directly with the insurer before purchasing.

What Simply Business actually is

Simply Business is an online insurance brokerage and marketplace for small and micro businesses. Instead of underwriting policies itself, it collects details about your business once and then surfaces options from a panel of partner insurance carriers. You answer a single set of questions — your trade, revenue, headcount, location — and the platform returns quotes you can compare side by side.

That model is the whole point. A direct carrier like Hiscox quotes you on its own products. A marketplace like Simply Business puts several carriers in front of you from one form, so you shop the market without filling out the same questionnaire five times. For common lines — general liability, a business owner's policy (BOP), professional liability, and workers' compensation — that breadth is the feature people come for.

Be precise about what this means: when you buy through Simply Business, the policy is issued by the underlying carrier, not by Simply Business, and claims are usually handled by that carrier too. This is normal for a marketplace, but it is the most important thing to understand before you treat it as "your insurer." It is not — it is the front door.

Affiliate disclosure, plainly: the link below is a partner link. If you start a quote through it, CoverBench may earn a commission at no cost to you, and that does not change how we rate Simply Business or where it lands in our comparisons.

If you want to see the live marketplace and what it quotes for your specific trade, you can start a free quote with Simply Business and compare the carriers it returns.

Marketplace vs buying direct: where Simply Business fits

The honest way to evaluate Simply Business is not in isolation — it is against the two realistic alternatives a small business owner is choosing between. The table below frames that decision. Monthly figures are illustrative bands drawn from commonly cited public averages for low-risk small businesses, not quotes.

Compare quotes: Start a free quote with Simply Business

A few takeaways. If your goal is to put several prices side by side without repeating yourself, a marketplace is structurally the better tool — exactly the job Simply Business is built to do. If you already know you want a specific carrier (say you researched Hiscox for professional liability), going direct removes a middle layer and lets you manage the policy in one place. And if your trade is unusual or has been declined elsewhere, a marketplace's panel gives you more shots at a carrier willing to write it.

Strengths reported by users

Based on Simply Business's published service description and reports from owners who have used it, the consistent positives are:

• Genuine comparison from one form. Answer once, see several carriers — the most cited reason people use it, and a real time-saver versus quoting carriers one at a time.
• Niche and micro-business friendly. Reviews frequently mention success placing smaller or specialized trades (cleaners, handymen, fitness instructors, consultants) that some direct carriers price awkwardly or decline.
• Fast online intake. The questionnaire is reported to be straightforward, with quotes returned quickly and the option to buy online for many trades.
• Human help available. A brokerage model means licensed agents you can reach if your situation needs a person — useful when you are unsure which lines you actually need.

Weaknesses and trade-offs to weigh

A credible review has to name the downsides, and there are real ones:

• It is a broker, not a carrier. Your policy and your claims live with the underlying insurer. If you value a single brand that quotes, services, and pays claims end to end, a direct carrier may feel cleaner.
• Contact volume after a quote. Users commonly report a jump in calls, texts, or emails after starting a quote — a pattern across insurance marketplaces. If you are sensitive to follow-up, expect outreach and be ready to say "just comparing."
• Available quotes depend on your state and trade. A marketplace only helps if its partner carriers write your line in your state. Which carriers appear can vary regionally, so what one owner sees is not necessarily what you will.
• You still have to read the policy. Comparing prices is easy; comparing coverage takes attention. The cheapest quote is not automatically the right one — limits, exclusions, and deductibles differ between carriers.

Illustrative figures only. Any dollar amount in this review is an illustrative band based on public averages — not a quote, binding offer, or insurance advice. Your actual premium depends on your specific business, location, claims history, coverage limits, and the carrier. Check current terms directly before you buy.

Our research-based CoverBench take

Weighing the published information and user reports above, here is how we assess Simply Business as an editorial, research-based judgment (not a measured test):

• Carrier choice & comparison: strong — this is its core advantage.
• Online quoting speed: strong — single intake, fast turnaround reported.
• Coverage breadth: broad, but carrier-dependent — confirm your specific lines.
• Best-fit clarity: clearest for shop-and-compare owners and hard-to-place trades; weakest if you already know your carrier or want one brand for everything.

That nets out to a simple rule of thumb: use Simply Business when you want to compare; buy direct when you already know.

Who should use Simply Business — and who shouldn't

Consider Simply Business if you:

• want several carriers' prices for the same coverage without filling out multiple forms,
• run a niche, micro, or seasonal business that direct carriers price awkwardly,
• are buying for the first time and want options (and a human to ask) rather than committing blind,
• need to add workers' comp as you hire and want to compare comp carriers in one place.

Consider buying direct instead if you:

• have already researched a carrier (for example, Hiscox for strong professional-liability terms) and want to buy and manage it in one place — you can get a free quote from a direct carrier through the marketplace too, or go straight to the insurer,
• strongly prefer one brand to quote, service, and handle claims end to end,
• dislike post-quote follow-up and want the most self-serve experience.

The decision is low-stakes to test: getting a quote is free and non-binding. The practical move is to run your details through the marketplace to see your carrier options, and — if you have a specific insurer in mind — compare that against a direct quote, then choose on coverage and price together, not price alone.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Simply Business an insurance company?

No. Based on its published description, Simply Business is an online insurance brokerage and marketplace, not a carrier. It collects your business details once and returns quotes from a panel of partner insurers. The policy you buy is issued by the underlying carrier, and claims are generally handled by that carrier — Simply Business is the broker that helps you find and bind coverage.

Is Simply Business legit and safe to use?

Simply Business is a real, established insurance marketplace that connects small businesses with licensed carriers. As with any quote service, the main thing users report to watch for is follow-up contact after starting a quote. None of this is a safety endorsement — verify the specific carrier behind any quote, read the policy terms, and confirm the insurer's licensing and reputation before you buy. This is general information, not insurance advice.

Is it cheaper to use Simply Business or buy direct?

It depends on your trade, state, and the carriers available to you — there is no universal answer. A marketplace can surface a cheaper carrier you would not have quoted on your own, but a direct carrier sometimes prices its own products competitively for low-risk trades. The reliable approach is to get a marketplace quote and a direct quote and compare them on coverage and price. Any figures here are illustrative averages, not quotes; check current terms with the insurer.

What types of small business insurance can I compare on Simply Business?

Reported lines commonly include general liability, a business owner's policy (BOP), professional liability (E&O), and workers' compensation, among others. Exactly which lines and carriers appear depends on your business type and state, so the cleanest way to know what is available for your trade is to start a free quote and review the options it returns for your specific profile.